Return of property

Judge Joe Brown

EPISODE VITALS

  • Show Judge Joe Brown
  • Date Added Nov 30, -1
  • Season 1
  • Episode 8
  • Ruling in favor of defendant
Amount of ruling: $1275
WATCH EPISODE

QUICK OVERVIEW

Plaintiff is suing for the return of a guitar. Defendant is countersuing for half the cost of a trip, car repair bills, rent, and, return of property.

EPISODE DESCRIPTION

Parties were room mates. Plaintiff claims she kept the guitar because defendant owes her money. Plaintiff claims defendant knew he had financial problems and knew he was not going to pay for the trip. Defendant showed evidence with their handwriting of a log of charges they were keeping on the trip to split it later. Defendant claims plaintiff wrecked her car. Judge rules that parties return to each other what belongs to them.

ABOUT Judge Joe Brown

Joseph "Judge Joe" Brown is an American lawyer. He is a former Shelby County, Tennessee, Criminal Court judge and a former arbiter of the arbitration-based reality court show, Judge Joe Brown

ABOUT THE PLAINTIFF

plaintiff
Charles McGarvey

ABOUT THE DEFENDANT

defendant
Melissa Hore

defendant plaintiff defendant witness

Comment (3)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *