Value of Personal Property

Judge Mathis

EPISODE VITALS

  • Show Judge Mathis
  • Date Added Apr 24, 2018
  • Season 5
  • Episode 4
  • Ruling in favor of plaintiff
Amount of ruling: $2108
WATCH EPISODE

QUICK OVERVIEW

Plaintiff is suing for the value of Personal Property, $2358. Defendant is countersuing for unpaid rent, $500.

EPISODE DESCRIPTION

Parties used to be roommates. Plaintiff claims that she had to move as defendant bullied her, had her as some kind of prisoner in jail always wanting to know her whereabouts. Defendant claims that plaintiffs behavior was shady, used to smoke pot in front of her kids and she suspect she was working as a prostitute. Plaintiff claims she gave her notice that she was moving, she told her she wont give her her property until she paid the $500 she owed her and changed the locks. Defendant claims she spoke to plaintiffs parents and told her they could come to pick up her belongings, plaintiffs mother owns some of the items. Defendant finally admits that she is holding her property hostage because she owes her money and that she disposed of some of the property. Judge awarded claim to plaintiff, minus $250 as part of the rent.

ABOUT Judge Mathis

Judge Mathis is a former Detroit-area district court judge. He listens to diverse litigants plead small-claims cases in his TV courtroom. A regular segment, Ask Judge Mathis, features the judge answering viewer questions to advise people with legal situations that they face. Prior to entering the legal world, Mathis was involved with gangs and spent time in jail as a young man before turning his life around.

ABOUT THE PLAINTIFF

plaintiff
Amanda Calchera

Charlotte, NC

ABOUT THE DEFENDANT

defendant
Kayla Rojas

Charlotte, NC

plaintiff defendant defendant plaintiff courtroom defendant defendant witness witness plaintiff defendant bailiff

Comment (3)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *